General Marketing

Streaming Aced Q3. Now Grade Your Own Ads.

The Q3 report cards are in, and they all say the same thing: the audience and the ad money keep moving to streaming and live sports while pay TV shrinks. But an earnings report grades the seller, not you. Here's how brand owners should read it before the holiday and Q1 plan.

Remember report card day?

You'd open the envelope, scan for the big letters, and know in two seconds how the term went.

Earnings season is report card day for TV. And this week, right before Thanksgiving, the last of the Q3 cards came in.

AdExchanger rounded them all up under one headline that says it all: "Pay TV Shrinks, Streaming And Sports Step Up."

Every card tells the same story. The audience and the ad money keep moving to streaming and live sports.


What Did the Report Cards Say?

Here are the grades, all from the companies' own results for the three months ending Sept. 30, according to AdExchanger:

  • Netflix: advertising revenue "has spiked over 80% this year." Overall revenue grew 12% to $12.9 billion.
  • Fox: a 47% jump in advertising revenue. Tubi, its free streaming service, grew viewing hours 23%.
  • Comcast: Peacock posted its second profitable quarter in a row, with paid subscribers up 17% to 48 million.
  • Skydance: Paramount+ revenue up 21% to just over $2.1 billion. Paramount+ and Pluto now run on the same ad tech stack.
  • Disney: entertainment ad revenue up 10% to $1.7 billion, and sports ad revenue up 20%.
  • Fubo: ad revenue of $119.1 million, up from $97.5 million a year earlier.
  • Versant: total revenue down 4%, blamed mostly on pay-TV declines. But its nonlinear revenue, streaming and direct-to-consumer, grew 10%.

Read that last one twice. Even where the total went down, the streaming side went up.

That's the whole map in one line.


Live Sports Got Extra Credit

Sports had a big term.

Disney's sports segment grew ad revenue 20%, according to AdExchanger's Disney coverage. It pointed to expanded college football rights, higher Monday Night Football ratings and ESPN's first ever Super Bowl telecast.

Live games are the closest thing TV has to a guaranteed crowd. People watch them live, together, ads and all. And more of them are on streaming every season.

We've written about how to buy and measure live sports on streaming. The short version: the crowd is there, and you can buy it by area and read it in your own sales.


And the Shelf Is About to Get Bigger

The next term brings more ad space, not less.

According to AdExchanger:

  • Disney is unifying Disney+ and Hulu into one app starting in December.
  • Disney is exploring a free streaming product. CEO Josh D'Amaro said it plainly: "It's going to give us more ad inventory to sell."
  • Skydance plans a combined HBO Max and Paramount+ service at the beginning of next year. That's two big libraries under one roof.
  • Fubo's pro and elite subscribers now get the ad-supported Disney+ and Hulu bundle at no extra cost.
  • Fox completed its Roku acquisition on Nov. 6.

More apps rolled together. More free tiers. More inventory on fewer, bigger stacks.

That's great news for brands. Buying streaming TV is getting easier every quarter.


Here's the Part Nobody Talks About

An earnings report grades the seller. It doesn't grade you.

When a company's ad revenue jumps 47%, that tells you advertisers are buying. It tells you nothing about whether *your* ads sold anything.

Those are two different report cards. Only one of them is yours.

And as the shelf gets bigger, the gap between those two cards gets wider. When inventory is easy to buy, anybody can spend. The brands that pull ahead are the ones that can prove what their spend did.

So the question for your holiday and Q1 plan isn't "Is streaming working?" The audience already answered that. The question is "Can I show what streaming did for *my* sales?"


Why This Matters Before Turkey Day

Timing matters here.

For a lot of brands, this is when holiday flights are set and Q1 starts to take shape. That's the moment these report cards are most useful.

They tell you where the crowd is sitting: on streaming apps, on free streaming services, and in front of live games. That should shape where your budget goes.

They don't tell you which of those buys will pay you back. That part you have to measure yourself, in your own sales, starting with the very first flight.

Set up the measurement before the money goes out, not after. It's the cheapest fix in media.


What Should a Brand Owner Do With This?

Four things.

1. Follow the audience. The people are on streaming and live sports. Plan where they are, not where they were. We made that case in TV's inflection point: TV didn't decline, it moved, and the audience moved with it.

2. Judge every app on the same yardstick. More apps and bundles means more price tags. Don't let a cheap impression in one app fool you. Compare every buy on cost per sale. We've laid out why: stop shopping the CPM and start shopping the cost per sale.

3. Read results in your own sales, by area. Hold out a few areas where the ads don't run and compare them to the ones where they do. That shows you the real lift your TV is creating, not the sales that would have happened anyway. Then check it against platform reports and your own order data.

4. Don't buy a platform because it had a good quarter. A strong earnings report is a great sign for the business. It's not a forecast for your campaign. Test it, read it in your sales, then scale what works.


The Honest Asterisk

Let's read these report cards the right way.

These are company-reported results. Several of the big numbers blend advertising with subscription and other revenue, so not every headline figure is pure ad growth.

Ad growth for a seller isn't proof of performance for a buyer. It means demand is strong. It doesn't mean every campaign worked.

And a growing ad business and a growing audience aren't always the same thing. Netflix grew ad revenue more than 80% this year, but its viewership was up just 2% over the first half of the year, according to AdExchanger. Co-CEO Ted Sarandos said engagement is "not growing as fast as I want us to." Netflix also touted new measurement tools, including a pixel to measure conversions, which is exactly the direction buyers want.

None of that is a knock on streaming. The momentum is real, and it's pointed one way. It just means you grade your own work with your own numbers.


The Final Take

The Q3 report cards are in, and streaming got the A.

Netflix, Fox, Peacock, Paramount+, Disney, Fubo. Growth up and down the list. Live sports up. Even where pay TV shrank, the streaming side grew.

The people are on streaming. Go where they are this holiday and into Q1.

But remember whose report card that is. Their earnings grade the seller. Your sales grade you.

Judge every app on cost per sale. Read the results in your own sales, by area, with holdouts. And scale what you can prove, not what had a good quarter on Wall Street.

That's how we plan and measure every campaign at CS & Co. It's built into the CS Method™. Want to see what streaming TV could do for your sales? Find out if CTV is a fit.

Cory Poccia
CEO, CS & Co. Marketing Studio™

Filed under CTV NewsGeneral Marketing

Cory Poccia, Founder & CEO of CS & Co. Marketing Studio. In media since 2004; teaches Media and Artificial Intelligence at Adelphi University.

One way to start

Is CTV right for your business?

If CTV is right for your business, we'll show you the math. If it's not, we'll tell you that too — before you spend a dollar.

Find out if CTV is a fit